Volume 24, Issue 1 | Spring 2025

Practicing Art HistoryA Perspective from the Archives

by Anne Helmreich

Evidence n. information indicating whether a belief or proposition is true or valid. Law information drawn from personal testimony, a document, or a material object, used to establish facts in a legal investigation or admissible as testimony in a law court. Signs; indications. V. be or show evidence of.

- Concise Oxford English Dictionary

To develop our hypotheses and then construct our arguments as art historians, we rely on evidence, often with the work of art—our material object—as the central subject of our inquiry. We scour archives and—with the rise of print culture, the industrial revolution, and the bureaucratic nation state in the nineteenth century, among other factors—our range of archival evidence is considerable as when compared, for example, to our peers studying the medieval period. We also understand that evidence can be complex, ambiguous, slippery, elusive, and even missing. In the pursuit of that evidence—the how and why it came to be saved or to be found—can often fade into the background: a side story to our art historical narrative at hand.

To those who care for archives, however, those side stories are the main event. What evidence is saved for the future is their main concern. Those charged with collecting and selecting archives relating to art must constantly ask themselves: what is the long-term research value of these materials when looking at the vast variety of artifacts that are the remaining traces of, for example, the artist, art historian, arts organization, art gallery—the vast constellation of people and bodies that make up the arts ecosystem?

I currently serve as the Director of the Archives of American Art (AAA), an organization dedicated to collecting, preserving, and making available primary sources relating to the visual arts of the United States. We undertake this work to empower an expansive history of art. We also take an expansive approach to what might appear to be a very bounded project given our name. We collect records relating to foreign artists who were active in the United States and US nationals who practiced abroad. We are deeply committed to ensuring that we collect the papers and oral histories associated with groups historically understudied in narratives of the history of the arts in the United States.

Jacques Derrida, in his exegesis on the nature of the archive, shaped by a reading of Yosef Hayim Yerushalmi’s Freud’s Moses: Judaism Terminable and Interminable, asserts that “the archive has always been a pledge, and like every pledge [gage], a token of the future.”‍[1] To my mind, that pledge is an implicit one of trust that we make for this and succeeding generations—you can trust that these resources will persist; you can trust that they are being treated responsibly. This trust is intimately tied to evidence—for evidence to carry weight in a scholarly argument, it must be verifiable; it must be persistent. And, it should also be open to debate and interpretation, which means it must be accessible. This enormous responsibility and the labor required to realize it at the highest ethical level can also fade into the background of our art historical narratives.

In practicing art history, how often do we recognize that we are also practicing archives? Our work depends on the work of the cultural heritage community, the various professions that make up the Galleries, Libraries, Archives, and Museums (GLAM) sector. In many ways, my professional journey, from academia to the archives, has been a journey to the very essence of what makes art history possible: evidence. As a steward of evidence, it is also tremendously beneficial that I understand, from lived experience, the value of that evidence from the perspectives of a scholar, teacher, digital humanist, and funder, to briefly encapsulate my previous professional experiences.

Effective collections stewardship is a team effort, relying on professional expertise and tight working relationships across groups that include administrators, archivists, collectors, curators, imaging specialists, project assistants, reference services, and registrars. And, like most thriving nonprofit arts organizations, our work also includes advancement and fundraising as well as outreach and engagement.

To guide our work going forward, our staff and advisory board have worked together over the past year to forge a new strategic plan for the coming five years. In previous roles, I have worked on strategic planning and found that having a collective organizational roadmap is invaluable; it helps to ensure everyone associated with the organization is heading in the same direction. Ideally, a good strategic plan also helps individuals understand how their roles and responsibilities contribute to the larger effort.

Guiding our work was a vision of the AAA as a vital and dynamic place to which visitors interested in understanding how art is essential to the human experience are drawn (rather than one of a dusty morgue enshrouded in mystery). We wanted to build on our culture of accessibility and on our tradition of welcoming visitors and inviting exploration within our collections. The AAA was also a pioneer in digitizing entire collections, and we wanted to continue to build on that history of innovation. In addition to exploring new ways to serve up collections beyond our physical walls, we also recognize the need to prepare for a born-digital future, that is, a future—which may already be here—in which the archival traces of artists, art historians, dealers, gallerists, teachers, and others are no longer primarily on paper but instead purely digital.

We have set out four goals. In forging these, we have had an opportunity to look backward as well as forward, reflecting on the journey we have traveled as an organization, and to consult with myriad stakeholders. Founded in 1954 in Detroit, Michigan, the AAA was the brainchild of Edgar P. Richardson, then Director of the Detroit Institute of Arts, and Lawrence A. Fleischman, businessman and art collector. Their original vision was to bring together evidence about the history of art in the United States through microfilming: primary sources would be imaged by the AAA and, once captured on microfilm, returned to their original homes.

Journalist Aline B. Saarinen wrote an insightful overview of those early years that continues to resonate with us. Her opening declared that “the Archives contains an incredible, fascinating and heterogenous treasure.” It had a systematic and inclusive purpose: she adds, “Its intention is to try to collect as much as possible of the original records of American painters, sculptors, craftsmen, collectors, dealers, critics, historians, museums, societies, and institutions.” She continues, “Its scope includes anything that may throw light upon the arts in America. Wisely, oh!, so very wisely, the Archives staff does not, by selecting and editing, try to guess the judgment of the future. They are themselves historians and researchers who know that the despised today may be the darling of tomorrow and that what may appear today to be but a trivial and tedious scrap of correspondence may be a keystone for research in the future.”‍[2]

Under the directorship of William E. Woolfenden, who oversaw the successful transfer of the AAA to the Smithsonian Institution in 1970 and retired from the organization in 1983, the organization expanded its remit to include collecting original materials, and, by the close of his tenure, the organization had “grown to some ten million documents and half a million photographs.”‍[3] Amongst its earliest acquisitions were the papers of The Macbeth Gallery—and, as a scholar of the history of the art market, I am deeply grateful that they retrieved these materials from an attic in Vermont. During this period, the AAA also launched its unique oral history program. Today, it holds well over twenty million letters, diaries, sketches and preparatory works, scrapbooks, manuscripts, financial records, photographs, films, and audiovisual recordings of artists, dealers, collectors, critics, scholars, museums, galleries, associations, and other art-world individuals and institutions; its oral history collection features over 2,600 long-form interviews.

Looking ahead, we have pledged to continue to collect and to steward “a national collection that represents the breadth and depth of the visual arts of the United States.”‍[4] This will entail not only continuing to capture the voices and stories of individuals, organizations, and institutions that represent significant contributions to the art world—in both analog and digital formats—but also space planning to anticipate our future growth patterns. We are also engaging with preservation planning, so we can care for fragile materials and changing artistic formats.

Our culture of access, closely linked to our engagement with new technologies dating back to our founding days and use of microfilm, informs our goal “to increase access to our collections and content by focusing on users, improving user experience, and leveraging digital technologies and innovative approaches.” We are exploring several strategies to reach this goal, including improving discovery of our collections and content online while remaining committed to full transparency in our processes through publicly available documentation.‍[5] This work involves thinking about metadata (data about data), a topic that I was not exposed to in my graduate studies but that has since become critically important to my professional practice, particularly as it relates to my work in the digital humanities. I was extremely fortunate to have the opportunity to work with art historian and information specialist Murtha Baca on several projects, and from her I learned about metadata’s power and significance.‍[6] At the archives we have taken to heart Baca’s advice that “digitization does not equal access. The mere act of creating digital copies of collection materials does not make those materials findable, understandable, or utilizable to our ever-expanding audience of online users. But digitization combined with the creation of carefully crafted metadata can significantly enhance end-user access—and our users are the primary reason we create digital resources.”‍[7]

Thinking about users also means we must take up outreach and engagement. We recognize that there are audiences who have questions about the art of the United States but may not know what we do, what we collect, and how to access our materials. So how do we reach them? As Sue Ann Kendall reminded readers in a 1986 profile on the AAA, “The resources of the Archives are made available to the public for educational and research purposes.” While Kendall noted the persistence of our collecting mission, she also noted a new direction instituted by then director Richard Murray, who urged the organization to “put more emphasis on the research of its own materials for publications and exhibitions, resulting in more of a balance between input and output, that is, between the collection and preservation of documents, and the active contribution of knowledge to the history of American art and civilization.”‍[8] Murray’s dream of balance is, in hindsight, probably unachievable given the constant stream of incoming collections, but the point is well taken regarding the need to reach out and not just wait for users to come to us. Our strategic planning conversations on this topic also reminded me of those I held as Director of the Baker-Nord Center for the Humanities at Case Western Reserve University when we discussed how we could help external audiences understand the societal significance and impact of the humanities.

Conceiving our art historical work as a value proposition may not be an intuitive reflex, but it is a way of thinking worth developing. In other words, how does our work benefit others? For libraries and archives, outreach has become a key means by which to articulate and measure the value they provide.‍[9] The Society of American Archivists includes outreach as one of their key professional terms, associating it with promoting the use of archives, educating about archives, and advocating for archives, manifested through such outputs as “exhibits, publications, events, lecture series, social media, teaching and instruction, workshops, presentations, and tours.”‍[10]

Our outreach and engagement goal aims “to expand public engagement by activating our collections and content to connect to audiences, increase our visibility, and invite and foster creative uses.”‍[11] Under this umbrella, we have arrayed a range of strategic and selective activities, including our exhibition program, our emergent education program Teaching with Primary Sources, the Archives of American Art Journal, social media efforts, and sharing of staff expertise.

The AAA’s exhibitions, in my brief tenure, have been marked by a collaborative approach. When our gallery reopened after lock-down restrictions associated with COVID-19 lifted and audiences began to return to in-person activities, the staff charged with developing the initial exhibition in our new gallery space—located in the Donald W. Reynolds Center at the Smithsonian Institution—took a very democratic approach, inviting colleagues from across the organization to submit their top choices; hence the exhibition’s title, “Staff Picks,” an intentional throwback to the days of video stores and specially curated—and often curious—assemblages of staff selections that piqued customers’ interest. Staff were also invited to write their own labels, a wonderful reminder of the constellation of perspectives that are brought together in stewarding archives. As I write this essay, we are copresenting with the National Portrait Gallery Felix Gonzalez-Torres: Always to Return, cocurated by Josh Franco, national collector for the AAA, and Charlotte Ickes, curator of time-based media and special projects at the National Portrait Gallery. The exhibition invites reflection on the nature of portraiture and art’s engagement with history. To develop the exhibition, the curators adopted a deeply researched and highly thoughtful and interactive approach, one attuned to the very nature of the artist’s work and the archival traces of his network of friends and family in the final display, likewise a collaborative undertaking, drawing on various expertise.‍[12]

Although the AAA lacks a staff position dedicated solely to education, supporting learning is infused throughout our organizational culture. We exist so that questions can be answered, and on any given day our reading room is populated with faculty and students as well as museum professionals and others active in the arts and culture sector. Yet we recognize the benefits of designing a program specifically focused on advancing pedagogy. Launched in 2019 as a partnership between the AAA; the Lunder Institute for American Art, Colby College; and the Cleveland Museum of Art, the first iteration of Teaching with Primary Sources brought together ten participants in a series of three workshops—each to be hosted by one of the partners—focused on using primary sources in the teaching of US art history.‍[13] The global pandemic disrupted the original plans for in-person gatherings but the pivot to online convenings proved fortuitous as it provided a model for subsequent iterations that have focused on using digitized resources and bringing together cohorts from diverse geographies. Currently, with the support of the Kress Foundation, we are experimenting, for the first time, with adopting a shared theme for the current offering of Teaching With Primary Sources. The topic of provenance encourages both the use of the AAA’s unique resources for new syllabi, classroom assignments, or teaching modules devoted to issues of provenance and faculty reflection on how they can help build students’ skills in this area and in anticipation of potential future career pathways.

Just as Teaching with Primary Sources centers archives, so does our publication, Archives of American Art Journal. Each issue features peer-reviewed articles from emerging to well established scholars, gathered under the rubric of “New Research,” bookended by short precises of recently acquired collections written by our staff. At the heart of the journal, as envisioned by Executive Editor Tanya Sheehan and Managing Editor Emily Shapiro, is “Archive Matters,” an artistic or curatorial intervention into the archives, helping us to see the selected materials afresh. The journal helps to carry out our commitment to an expansive history—one marked by pluralities—of US art.

While the journal reaffirms our commitment to long-form writing and scholarly argumentation, we, like nearly every GLAM organization, have also taken up social media and short-form storytelling to connect to audiences, sharing quick updates and enticing visuals relating to our collections and activities. Our goal here is to help make our content more discoverable and relevant to audiences.

Crafting social media posts that encourage positive interactions (e.g., “likes” and reposting) may seem far away from stewarding evidence, but these actions are part of a larger ecosystem. Put another way, for an archival document to become evidence, it requires an interlocuter—someone to activate, interpret, and to deploy that archival trace in the service of an argument; someone to put that form of evidence into a conversation with others, be they authors, theories, existing literature, or other bodies of evidence. The archive, keeping its pledge, waits for the reader to complete the circuit and spark connections of discovery, insight, animation, and argument.

Recognizing that this ecosystem would not be possible without our talented and amazing staff, we have also framed a goal around sustainability dedicated to ensuring “that we have the people, infrastructure, and resources to deliver our mission and vision.”‍[14] This is truly the behind-the-scenes work that most scholars will never see; but it is absolutely essential for our long-term stability and the persistence of the primary sources—the evidence—we hold in trust. For every reader’s appointment made, for every cart of archival boxes brought to our reading room from storage, for every question answered, for every digitization request fulfilled, for every exhibition loan provided, for every article published, for every exhibition mounted, for every teachers’ workshop held, for every study day organized—for all these activities and many more—there are myriad steps taken, workflows developed, and costs incurred.

The GLAM sector has typically taken the approach that when we do our job well, this effort may not even be discernible to users. But from my perspective, gained from my professional journey that began with giving public lectures in galleries and teaching undergraduate students, the public is eager to learn more about these behind-the-scenes activities. Drawing back the curtain can help the public understand why supporting this work is so important—why we must fundraise to meet our commitments—and introduce students to potential career pathways. And understanding the intellectual work that underlies selecting, describing, arranging, and sharing collections can, from my perspective, only strengthen the scholarship on which it is built. In other words, rather than taking the act of discovering evidence for granted and as self-evident, recognizing the choices and actions of others that underlie these building blocks of scholarship can allow us, as scholars, to deploy that evidence with more thought and care when practicing art history.

On NCAW home page: William Macbeth, Art Notes, November–December 1896. Macbeth Gallery records, 1947-–1948, Archives of American Art, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, DC. Image in the public domain; courtesy of the Archives of American Art, Smithsonian Institution.

Notes

[1] Jacques Derrida, “Archive Fever: A Freudian Impression,” trans. Eric Prenowitz, Diacritics 25, no. 2 (Summer 1995): 18. Emphasis in original.

[2] Aline B. Saarinen, “Building Archives of our Art,” The New York Times, July 26, 1959, 277.

[3] William E. Woolfenden, Ruth Bowman, and Emily Nathan, “William E. Woolfenden and the Archives of American Art: 1954–1953,” Archives of American Art Journal 23, no. 1 (1983): 3.

[4] “Archives of American Art Strategic Plan, FY25–FY29,” June 4, 2024.

[5] “Internal Procedures and Guidelines,” Archives of American Art, https://www.aaa.si.edu/.

[6] See the following special issues of Visual Resources: Murtha Baca and Anne Helmreich, eds., “Board Approved Special Issue: Digital Art History,” special issue, Visual Resources 29, no. 1–2 (2013); Murtha Baca and Anne Helmreich, eds., “Digital Art History,” special issue, Visual Resources 35, no. 1–2 (2019). See also Murtha Baca and Anne Helmreich, eds., “DAH Case Studies,” Getty Iris Blog, February 15, 2017, http://blogs.getty.edu/; and Murtha Baca, ed. Introduction to Metadata, 3rd ed. (Los Angeles: Getty Publications, 2016), http://www.getty.edu/.

[7] Murtha Baca, “Introduction,” in Baca, Introduction to Metadata, n.p.

[8] Sue Ann Kendall, “Archives of American Art/Smithsonian Institution,” Art Documentation: Journal of the Art Libraries Society of North America 5, no. 3 (Fall 1986): 107.

[9] Stephanie Graves, Sarah LeMire, Kristen Mastel, and Shannon Farrell, “Demonstrating Library Value Through Outreach Goals and Assessment,” Educause, August 13, 2018, https://er.educause.edu/.

[10] Dictionary of Archives Terminology, s.v. “outreach,” https://dictionary.archivists.org/.

[11] “Archives of American Art Strategic Plan, FY25-FY29,” June 4, 2024.

[12] Nathan Pugh, “From Candy to Lightbulbs, Felix Gonzalez-Torres Showed Life and Loss Through Everyday Objects,” Smithsonian Magazine, October 21, 2024, https://www.smithsonianmag.com/.

[13] For more on the Archives of American Arts’s Teaching with Primary Sources workshop series, see Archives of American Art, “Teaching with Primary Sources,” accessed February 16, 2025, https://www.aaa.si.edu/; “In Conversation: Teaching with Primary Sources,” Archives of American Art Journal 61, no. 2 (Fall 2022): 70–85; Liza Kirwin, “Teaching with Primary Sources,” introduction to In the Round, Panorama: Journal of the Association of Historians of American Art 5, no. 2 (Fall 2019), https://doi.org/10.24926/24716839.2298.

[14] “Archives of American Art Strategic Plan, FY25-FY29,” June 4, 2024.