Rethinking American Art: Collectors, Critics, and the Changing Canon by Theodore E. Stebbins Jr., with the research assistance of Susan E. Stebbins
Reviewed by Kim OrcuttKim Orcutt
Independent scholar
Email the author: kimorcutt301[at]gmail.com
Citation: Kim Orcutt, book review of Rethinking American Art: Collectors, Critics, and the Changing Canon by Theodore E. Stebbins Jr., with the research assistance of Susan E. Stebbins, Nineteenth-Century Art Worldwide 25, no. 1 (Spring 2026), https://doi.org/10.29411/ncaw.2026.25.1.11.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License
unless otherwise noted.
Your browser will either open the file, download it to a folder, or display a dialog with options.
Theodore E. Stebbins Jr., with the research assistance of Susan E. Stebbins,
Rethinking American Art: Collectors, Critics, and the Changing Canon.
Godine, 2025.
432 pp.; 74 color illus.; index; notes.
$55.00 (hardcover)
ISBN: 9781567928341
In Rethinking American Art, distinguished curator Theodore E. Stebbins Jr. offers a rigorously researched account of the American artistic canon, but also an account shaped by his career as a scholar, curator, and collector observing the field’s changes over the years. The author aims to describe how the canon has developed from the early nineteenth century to the present through the people who created and were affected by those changes: art historians, critics, artists, and collectors.
Stebbins begins his account with William Dunlap, the early nineteenth-century historian of American art, and adds his own experiences and observations gleaned over the past sixty years of the field’s growth, maturation, and expansion. For Stebbins, “the canon refers both to the short list of artists most valued by any generation and to the aesthetic standards of each period” (7). He counters “art history, with its grand narrative describing ‘the evolution of movements, schools, styles, periods, and eras’ and its concomitant definition of a number of painters and sculptors as representing ‘the highest achievements of European and later Euro-American material cultures’—the old canon in other words” (7–8) with the views of modern scholars who oppose past hierarchies of race, gender, and class.
The book is divided into three sections—“Critics and Canons,” “The Collectors,” and “Today”—that progress chronologically, with each section emphasizing different constituencies’ contributions to the canon. I should note that Stebbins uses the term American throughout the book to refer to the field, but he is aware that the geographic and cultural scope of the term has evolved along with the canon.
Chapter 1, “Changing Canons in the Nineteenth Century,” begins with the first histories of American art, starting with Dunlap’s History of the Rise and Progress of the Arts of Design in the United States (1834), which was based on biographies of artists he favored, such as Benjamin West and Washington Allston. Stebbins progresses to Henry Tuckerman’s Book of the Artists (1867), which built on Dunlap’s account by adding living painters, critique, and analysis. James Jackson Jarves’s The Art Idea (1865) foreshadowed the growing interest in French art in the 1880s and the decline of interest in the Hudson River School style. In 1880, S. J. W. Benjamin’s Art in America described the transition from detailed realism to a freer and more evocative style. Edward Strahan’s The Art Treasures of America (1879) detailed the holdings of major American collectors. The author notes how all collections tended to look a great deal alike, “as they do in every era” (17–18). Comparing George W. Sheldon’s American Painters (1879) to his subsequent Recent Ideals of American Art (1888), Stebbins shows the writer’s transition from favoring the Hudson River School to French-influenced painters. Other key works include Clarence Cook’s Art and Artists of Our Time (1888) and Walter Montgomery’s American Art and American Art Collections (1889).
A few key collectors are also noted. William T. Evans “lacked an adventurous eye” and “kept on buying a canon already going out of fashion” (24); and Thomas B. Clarke was “the outstanding collector-dealer the late nineteenth century” (25). Clarke’s collection evolved over time from Hudson River painters Thomas Cole and Albert Bierstadt to more evocative landscapists such as Homer Dodge Martin, George Inness, and Winslow Homer.
An illuminating aspect of the book is Stebbins’s attention to artists who were well known in their time but are no longer, such as George Fuller and Martin. Stebbins summarizes three major chronological shifts: 1) the rise of Cole and Frederic E. Church and the rejection of Dunlap’s roster; 2) the rise of French-influenced figure and landscape art; and 3) the preference for rugged scenes by native artists, such as Homer, culminating in the 1900 Paris Exposition, where the shift in interest from French influence to a distinctly American sensibility was confirmed.
After this point in the book, discussions of writing on and collecting of nineteenth-century art make an important shift from discussing the art of the present to discussing the art of the past. Chapter 2, “The Rise of Museums and Professional Critics,” moves into the early twentieth century, when museums began to seriously collect American art and art writing became increasingly professionalized. Stebbins describes books by William Howe Downes and ambitious surveys by Sadakichi Hartmann, Charles H. Caffin, and Samuel Isham, noting that all began by rejecting the canons of early writers like Dunlap and Tuckerman.
Hartmann advocated for the “native art” of Homer and Thomas Eakins and considered the standard bearer for the future of American art to be the once acclaimed and now obscure George Fuller. Caffin was similar, and he also admired James McNeill Whistler and the American Impressionists Childe Hassam and John Henry Twachtman. Stebbins has great praise for Isham’s History of American Painting (1905); it became the standard text for decades after, and Isham was the first to recognize the expatriate triumvirate of John Singer Sargent, Whistler, and Mary Cassatt, along with other Paris-trained Americans.
At the turn of the century, major art museums started to build their American collections. All “acted in unison, following the same playbook” (37). They were mainly interested in Homer, Sargent, and Whistler, with Cassatt, Albert Pinkham Ryder, and Inness in their wake. Stebbins considers the Metropolitan Museum of Art (The Met) the most farsighted in its collecting during this period. His experience and wisdom are apparent in his analysis of The Met’s early success: “Great acquisitions are typically the result of a combination of factors: an energetic curator with a passion for the material, an understanding board, a cooperative director, and adequate funding” (39–40). He also points out the decline of Sargent’s and Fuller’s reputations; the former’s renown would return, but the latter’s did not.
The author turns to the development of other major collections. The Museum of Fine Arts Boston (MFA) showed early initiative, particularly with “local” artists such as Homer and Sargent, who undertook several successful stays in the city painting portraits. Isabella Stewart Gardner was also a bold collector of the modern art of her day, particularly of Sargent and Whistler. Likewise, the Philadelphia Museum of Art’s collecting in the early twentieth century emphasized its own local artists, such as Eakins and the Peale family, while the Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts’s collection serves as an example of Dunlap’s canon, with an emphasis on West and Allston. The Art Institute of Chicago showed an early enthusiasm for the French Impressionists and Whistler, alongside Americans who worked in the Impressionist style. One can imagine the sigh accompanying Stebbins’s closing remark, “Those were the days” (50).
Chapter 3, “Important Mid-Century Writers: Goodrich, Sweet, Richardson,” briefly surveys the beginnings of American art as a field of study in the mid-twentieth century, focusing on five writers who characterized the period in their “nativism, their rejection of [John Singleton] Copley and the early painters, their lack of interest in the Hudson River School, their love of mural painting, and their anti-modernism” (55), in keeping with the views of the period. Early writers included Frank Jewett Mather, curator and advocate for John La Farge, Ryder, Homer, and Eakins; Royal Cortissoz, art critic for the New York Herald Tribune who favored Homer, Sargent, Ryder, and Whistler; and Homer Saint-Gaudens, Carnegie Institute director and son of the sculptor Augustus Saint-Gaudens.
They were succeeded by, in the author’s words, “a younger, abler group of scholars” (58) who set new standards for the field. Lloyd Goodrich was a conservative curator and later director of the Whitney Museum of American Art who famously advanced the trio of Homer, Ryder, and Eakins (his particular favorite), as well as then-living artists such as Reginald Marsh and Edward Hopper. As curator at the Art Institute of Chicago, Frederick A. Sweet organized important and farsighted exhibitions on the Hudson River School as well as one on Sargent, Whistler, and Cassatt. Edgar P. Richardson spent most of his career at the Detroit Institute of Arts and cofounded the Archives of American Art, an invaluable resource for scholars today.
The next chapter, “Americans Discover American Art,” recounts the lives and activities of major collectors from the 1960s to the early 2000s. Stebbins knew these collectors and was closely involved in key moments from the period, recalling, “Ambitious exhibitions, handsome scholarly publications, ever-higher auction prices, and a frenzied search for rarities” (67). Stebbins identifies a new generation of collectors of American art, such as Mr. and Mrs. Lawrence Fleischman of Detroit and Mr. and Mrs. Norman B. Woolworth of New York. He evaluates the quality of their collections based on key artists, works, and quality of examples. He segues into dealers with Fleischman, who took over Kennedy Galleries in New York, a rival to Hirschl & Adler (led by former Met curator and collector Stuart Feld), along with several other galleries. In the mid-1960s, another generation of “old money” collectors arose, including John D. Rockefeller III, J. William Middendorf, Barbara Millhouse, and John Wilmerding. Stebbins notes the great rediscoveries of that exciting period through major museum exhibitions of the work of Church, Fitz Henry Lane, and Martin Johnson Heade.
The tide of higher prices, scholarship, and exhibitions rose through the 1970s. Scholars such as Wilmerding and Barbara Novak published foundational works. In 1970, The Met mounted the pioneering exhibition “19th-Century America: Painting and Sculpture,” a “sprawling exhibition [that] defined the field as it was then understood” (75). In 1976, Wilmerding published his foundational survey, American Art. During his tenure as the National Gallery of Art’s first curator of American art, his exhibition “American Light” brought the theory of Luminism as a landscape movement to the fore.
Growing museum and scholarly interest led to an expanding market for nineteenth-century paintings. Stebbins relates fascinating “insider” stories of great discoveries and the various intrigues that brought them to their current homes, including Eastman Johnson’s The Cranberry Harvest (1880; Timken Museum of Art, San Diego), Bierstadt’s A Storm in the Rocky Mountains (1866; Brooklyn Museum, Brooklyn), and Church’s The Icebergs (1861; Dallas Museum of Art, Dallas).
Chapter 5, “Celebratory Exhibitions and Publications,” identifies Homer and Sargent as the two most venerated American artists at the end of the twentieth century. He notes major trends in museum exhibitions of the period, including the rediscovery of landscape painting through group exhibitions, monographic shows, and thematic exhibitions. John James Audubon is singled out as “a category of his own” (90), though his works are less often seen because most of them are watercolors, and his reputation is tarnished by the recognition that he was a slaveowner. Yet, as Stebbins acknowledges, “the works themselves remain as extraordinary as ever” (91). During the current century, several major exhibitions explored themes such as still life and watercolor, and some focused on individual artists. Stebbins deservedly singles out Barbara Haskell, whose work at the Whitney Museum encompassed dozens of groundbreaking exhibitions on important American modernists.
The author’s own decades of experience at the MFA included two important exhibitions that traveled to China in the early 1980s and to the Louvre in Paris in 1983, a period before international loans of American art were common. His recollections of exhibition preparations are vivid and illuminating. He also recounts a group of Black artists protesting the absence of Black artists in the Paris exhibition and the subsequent inclusion of a Henry Ossawa Tanner painting as an indication of evolving tastes, as “Americans were becoming aware of our history of racism and the changing standards for judging art” (94). Other institutions began to organize exhibitions of American art for international venues as well. Stebbins ends the chapter with what he deems “the last—and in many ways, the best—textbook of the old era” (95), Wayne Craven’s American Art: History and Culture (1993), which covered a wide range of media and employed traditional methodologies emphasizing biography, artistic movements, and stylistic influences.
The second section, titled “The Collectors,” introduces a colorful cast of—dare I say—characters, because they are so vividly brought to life in fascinating accounts of how major collections of American art were formed and the impact that they had on the field.
As the title of chapter 6, “The Wounded Collector: Grenville Winthrop,” suggests, Winthrop’s story is a sad one of a lonely, reclusive man who left his truly remarkable collection to Harvard University. His fortune was inherited from his father’s work in banking and his wife’s inheritance from her father, also a banker. Abandoned by his wife, who later died by suicide, his overcontrolling behavior also drove away his two daughters. Winthrop threw himself into collecting both Western and Eastern art. His most significant American purchases were watercolors by Sargent, watercolors and pastels by Whistler, and important watercolors by Homer. Near the end of his life he concentrated on historic paintings by Charles Willson Peale, West, Copley, and Thomas Sully.
Next, in chapter 7, Stebbins documents “The Ambitions of Francis P. Garvan,” Yale’s great American art benefactor. In contrast to Winthrop, Garvan was flamboyant and passionately focused on American art. The son of an Irish immigrant, he became a wealthy man through his wife’s inheritance and rose to the heights of New York Society. Garvan is well known for his decorative art collecting, but Stebbins focuses on his interest in paintings, miniatures, and prints. Though much of his collection was dispersed to pay estate taxes—a few works finding their way to Yale—Stebbins has reconstructed his collection and his interest in storytelling paintings by now lesser-known artists such as Edward Lamson Henry, Charles Deas, David Gilmour Blythe, Thomas Waterman Wood, and J. G. Brown, as well as late nineteenth-century figure painters such as Eakins, Abbott Handerson Thayer, and Whistler. He was also an early collector of Ashcan School painters including John Sloan, George Luks, and Robert Henri.
Chapter 8, “The Troubled Clark Brothers,” recounts the competitive collecting and mutual animosity of two heirs to the Singer Sewing Machine Company fortune, Robert Sterling Clark and Stephen Carlton Clark. Sterling is best known as founder of the Clark Art Institute in Williamstown, Massachusetts, while Stephen dispersed his collection among several institutions.
Sterling served in the army and then settled in Paris, marrying a French actress. After returning to the United States in 1912, he began collecting in earnest and planning his future museum. Many of his acquisitions were old masters and French Impressionist works; he also pursued great canvases by Homer and Sargent. In his later years, he turned to the work of Inness and the sculptor Frederic Remington. Stebbins describes his “discovery” of Stephen through his superb gifts to Yale ranging from Frans Hals to Edouard Manet, Jean-Baptiste-Camille Corot, and Pablo Picasso, as well as Homer, Hopper, and Eakins. The author presents a startling laundry list of remarkable works that Stephen acquired, helping to restore the collector’s rightful renown.
Chapter 9, “Maxim Karolik: Discovering a New Canon,” considers Karolik’s activities “the boldest collecting of American paintings and folk art that anyone accomplished at mid-century” (147). Karolik was a Ukrainian Jewish immigrant tenor who parlayed a private performance into a marriage to a wealthy Washington, DC, doyenne twice his age. His new wife collected early American furniture, silver, and paintings. Karolik quickly adopted her interest, and they began to make gifts to the MFA.
Karolik influenced the field by emphasizing the aesthetic merit rather than the historic significance of the objects he acquired. His “first collection” of decorative arts was succeeded by a new interest in paintings, and for his “second collection” he turned to nineteenth-century genre and landscape scenes. Karolik played a role in reviving the Hudson River School: Bierstadt was a particular favorite, along with Cole, John Frederick Kensett, Jasper Francis Cropsey, and others. He was also an adventurous collector of folk art.
A few years after his wife’s death in 1948, Karolik’s collection—by then 233 paintings by an astonishing array of antebellum artists—was installed at the MFA for five years. He continued to acquire artworks, beginning a “third collection” concentrating on American drawings. A selection of his vast holdings toured the nation in the 1950s, spreading Karolik’s “new canon” across the country.
In a fascinating and cautionary conclusion to Karolik’s remarkable story, Stebbins relates how the MFA director made the unwise but well-meaning gesture of making Karolik Honorary Curator of American Art. The “loud and blustery” Karolik took his new role far more literally than was intended, causing considerable disruption among the staff and trustees; the director privately called him “an insufferable burden” (168). Stebbins concludes that Karolik’s background and brash personality were not accepted by reserved Bostonians, but his collection certainly was.
As with other American art movements, “American Impressionism” was a later invention that allowed art historians to conveniently group artists by style. In chapter 10, “Ray & Margaret Horowitz and the Invention of American Impressionism,” Stebbins traces the formation of the moniker to museum exhibitions in the mid-twentieth century, around the time that Daniel and Rita Fraad began collecting American art. Daniel Fraad worked closely with Raymond Horowitz, and inspired the Horowitzes’ interest in American Impressionist painters in the 1960s. Works by then little-known artists such as Henri, William Merritt Chase, and Hassam represented an inexpensive alternative to French Impressionism. The Horowitzes eventually influenced the Fraads to collect American Impressionist works as well. Stebbins paints a vivid picture of Mr. and Mrs. Horowitz’s collecting activities, punctuated with colorful anecdotes that suggest the high adventure and joy—as well as obsession—of collecting. The Met mounted an exhibition of their collection in 1973, vaulting them and their artworks to a new level of prominence.
The 1980s saw two “complicated figures” (185) enter the field, scholar William H. Gerdts and collector Daniel J. Terra. Gerdts was and is remembered for his remarkable productivity and rigorous research. Terra collected important works from throughout the nineteenth century that led to the founding of the Terra Museum of American Art. In addition, his keen interest in American Impressionism resulted in a museum in Giverny, France, though unfortunately neither museum exists today.
Stebbins traces the fates of the Fraad and Horowitz collections, both of which were sold at auction. The sales “marked the height of the boom in American Impressionism” (193). The chapter concludes with a warm encomium to the Horowitzes: “Their secret was hardly a secret: They loved art, they remained true to their original visions, they were without guile, and they had excellent judgment both in paintings and people” (194).
Chapter 11, “Collecting the Canon During the Boom Years,” describes the market for historic American art at its height in the 1980s and 1990s. The best works of big-name artists had already been acquired, but dealers and collectors continued to enthusiastically pursue works that Stebbins frankly calls “second string artists at first string prices” (198). The author describes the rivalry between Terra of Chicago and Richard Manoogian of Detroit; Manoogian was a skilled buyer and seller and amassed an impressive and wide-ranging collection that was exhibited at museums across the country. Stebbins sketches out several influential collectors—their passions, their key acquisitions, and how their collections were dispersed. He concludes elegiacally, “The euphoria of those days is now long gone, and the enormous bubble these collectors created has collapsed. The great and even the good paintings are gone” (205).
Chapter 12 introduces “William H. Lane, Champion of Modern American Art” as “one of the two donors whose gifts exponentially raised the stature of the Museum of Fine Arts in the field of American art” (207) (the other being Karolik, discussed in chapter 9). Like Karolik, Lane was an outsider to Brahmin Boston; he was a gruff but passionate collector and a generous benefactor to the MFA. Lane began collecting in the 1950s and developed a remarkable modernist collection, including important works by Stuart Davis, Charles Sheeler, and Georgia O’Keeffe. Stebbins recounts the decades-long pursuit that grew into a warm and dedicated relationship between Mr. and Mrs. Lane and the MFA. Lane also collected photographs, including Sheeler’s entire corpus, which he purchased after the artist’s death to provide support to Sheeler’s widow, as well as important holdings of Ansel Adams and Edward Weston.
In 1991, the collection came to the MFA as a partial gift and purchase. The story of Stebbins’s relationship with the Lanes details the personal and administrative aspects of wooing a major collector and serves as an instructive case study for curators and collectors alike. Stebbins concludes that “Bill Lane was the purest collector, the most innocent one I ever knew. His financial return could have been astounding if he or his estate had chosen to cash in, but money was irrelevant to him, as it is for real collectors; it was only the art that mattered” (229).
In chapter 13, “Alice Kaplan, Only the Best,” Stebbins lauds Kaplan for the extraordinary range and high quality of her collecting. Kaplan began when she was nearly sixty and earned her master’s degree in art history from Columbia University. She served as President of the American Federation of Arts, among other leadership positions in public service. Instead of specializing, Kaplan’s collection ranged periods, geographies, and mediums, including many masterworks. Stebbins credits her with the equivalent of “perfect pitch” for musicians in her instinctive eye for quality (236). While Kaplan does not quite fit the mold of other collectors of American art profiled in the book, Stebbins considers her qualities as a collector worthy of mention.
In chapter 14, “The Problem of Collecting Contemporary Art: Richard Brown Baker, Joseph Helman, Monroe Price,” Stebbins discusses three collectors of contemporary art who experienced widely different levels of success at predicting what the canon would be—and which would stand the test of time. Helman successfully acquired late twentieth-century greats, Baker created a personal canon that did not achieve wider circulation, and Price paid no attention to the opinions of others.
Baker bought extensively and with high ambitions, wanting to create a great collection that could someday be a gift to Yale, his alma mater. His voluminous diaries, besides being deeply personal, include detailed accounts of four decades of collecting. His early acquisitions of American and European abstract painters showed great promise and brought him to the attention of the art world, but he did not embrace the movements that would define the canon from the 1970s on, making the gift of his collection to Yale—a daunting 1,344 works—a dilemma in terms of the resources required to house and care for the majority of the collection that would likely not be placed on view.
Helman represented a contrasting personality and collecting strategy. His first acquisition was a Jasper Johns painting, a distinguished beginning. He concentrated on what he considered a brief period of American preeminence in art, pursuing key works from Abstract Expressionism and Pop Art created from World War II to the Vietnam era. After a period of self-education, Helman became a dealer in St. Louis, championed by Emily Rauh Pulitzer and with her husband Joseph Pulitzer Jr. as a major client. Helman later opened a gallery in New York with Irving Blum and orchestrated a number of bold artist projects and exhibitions.
Monroe Price has specialized in the art of central Europe, buying works during his professional travels that speak to him emotionally and perhaps recall his own early life in Nazi-era Vienna.[1] Though most of the artists are unfamiliar, Stebbins calls his approach “a forerunner of today’s art that speaks to morality and justice” (271).
Chapter 15, “Alice Walton, Educator and Museum-Builder,” serves as a wrap-up to one canon and a transition to another. Stebbins identifies “the last hurrah for the traditional canon of the nineteenth- and early twentieth-century painters” (275) as 2005, when Walton announced that she would build a museum of American art in Bentonville, Arkansas; the Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art opened in 2011 to warm praise. Walton’s ambitious campaign to build a collection of historic American art, aided by Wilmerding, was remarkably successful given the rarity and expense of important works coming available by that point. The museum opened with a traditional installation, but within a few years “everything had changed. In a very short time, Alice had quickly recognized the moral imperatives of the new inclusionary, anti-racist canon” (283). The museum rapidly expanded its holdings to include works by Black, Native American, and women artists and mounted a new thematic installation. This is a turning point in the book where Stebbins asserts that “without declaring the old canon null and void, the curators proposed. . . a selection of works where ideas and themes, not individual painters, reign” (286–87).[2] Stebbins describes Walton’s Art Bridges Foundation, an initiative that develops traveling exhibitions, facilitates loans from the collections of large museum storage to small institutions, and is building its own collection of mostly modern and contemporary American art for lending purposes. Walton has also made generous grants to museums to improve public access by increasing free hours, providing bilingual programs, and offering virtual tours.
Part 3, “Today,” begins with chapter 16, “The Recognition of Racism and Misogyny.” Stebbins traces the history of major museums displaying the work of Black artists back to the 1960s, usually in the wake of protests over their exclusion from planning and participation, and the “separate canon” of Black artists that had developed with the support of Black press, artist collectives, galleries, private collectors, and initiatives such as the Harmon Foundation. He also recounts the rise of feminism and the greater recognition accorded to women artists in the late twentieth century.
During the early 2000s, the injustices of racism and slavery received increased attention from academics. This brought to light evils perpetrated by revered historic figures and led to renamings, monument removals, and museum efforts to expand holdings and exhibitions of Black and women artists. New surveys of American art by Frances Pohl and Angela Miller reflect this new methodology, “with all its merits and its confusion” (309). The revisions include attention to Native American art, Spanish colonial works, a broader range of mediums, and much more comprehensive coverage of Black and women artists. Prioritizing context over subject matter, the authors “see art through race- and gender-colored glasses” (310). This approach of course leaves less room for coverage of the “traditional” canon, and while Stebbins acknowledges the gaps in past accounts, he notes that in their many omissions, “a student relying on [one of the new surveys] would gain a somewhat skewed understanding of the history of American art” (311).
Chapter 17, “Museums Reset,” addresses how recent national discussions about racism have led museums to orient more of their efforts toward social justice initiatives, with Southern and Western museums leading the way. Stebbins considers Northeastern museums to have been more cautious, excepting the Brooklyn Museum. However, he points out initiatives at the MFA and The Met that date back to the 1970s as well as more recent efforts by the National Gallery and the Smithsonian American Art Museum (SAAM).
Stebbins addresses the dilemma that emerges from these campaigns to expand the canon: with limited gallery space, how much of the “old” canon is represented in the galleries? He contrasts The New York Historical, which has packed away most of its holdings in storage, with Crystal Bridges, which still has its best holdings on view. He also reviews reinstallations at three major museums and evaluates their efforts at incorporating the “new” canon: the Philadelphia Museum of Art, the MFA, and the Baltimore Museum of Art. Stebbins moves outside the realm of historic art to discuss contemporary Black and women artists who have recently benefited from deserved museum attention, such as Faith Ringgold, Robert Colescott, Kehinde Wiley, and Amy Sherald.
Chapter 18, “Native Americans, Reconsidered,” traces the growth of attention to Native American art. Museums began to question the myths of the historic American West beginning with SAAM’s 1991 exhibition, The West as America. While pioneering for museums, the exhibition followed the lead of revisionist studies in academia. Western museums were collecting Native American works as art as early as the 1920s, and Stebbins traces early efforts and exhibitions. Increasing Native American activism in the 1960s and 1970s led to the rise of contemporary Indigenous artists. In recent years Eastern art museums have engaged with Native American art as more than ethnographic evidence of dead cultures, as The Met, the MFA, and the National Gallery began purchasing the works of historic and present-day creators and mounting exhibitions of their work.
The final chapter is something of a grab bag of Stebbins’s reflections on the present-day art world. He compares the American field with that of scholarship on European art, where women artists such as Artemesia Gentileschi have received long-overdue public attention, and excellent scholarship based on archival research and connoisseurship is still being produced. He cites important recent exhibitions on European artists in the United States and notes that “there are few signs of the nervousness one finds in projects devoted to American art” (363).
Turning to the state of monographic exhibitions, Stebbins identifies recent trends toward examining the careers of “unsung artists,” while better known painters require new research to justify a loan exhibition at a major museum. Following is a series of mini-reviews of important shows on Homer, Sargent, Cassatt, and Cole, and a few notable recent monographs on Copley and Lane.
Stebbins then addresses the current market for historic American art and the new interest in portraits of historical figures, particularly of George Washington, and works representing or by Black and Native American artists, especially by museums, with several illuminating case studies. Major museums displaying and collecting contemporary art are relatively new phenomena; the author warns against “a vast network of smooth-talking advisors, scholars, curators, critics, and auctioneers stirring the mix” (377) and discusses a new generation of Black collectors.
Stebbins also notes the recent rise of eco-criticism as a methodology; he finds it hard to tell where the new methodology will lead and asks a reasonable question that curators face: once we have learned that a piece of early American furniture was made of wood harvested by enslaved people and it is labeled appropriately, is that work less beautiful or less important? He insightfully contrasts the goals of museumgoers who are likely seeking greatness through beauty, value, inspiration, and craftsmanship with those of curators and scholars who wish to follow current academic interests.
Stebbins concludes by comparing two recent reinstallations of the American art galleries at The Met and the Brooklyn Museum. He finds The Met installation marred by too many works of lesser quality, included to broaden the representation of Black and women artists. The Brooklyn Museum, however, earns his praise for its revisionist approach: here, “democracy rules, and there are few concessions to traditional notions of quality and importance” (388). The comparison is a little confusing; while he finds both to be neglecting questions of quality, it seems that this is a fault at The Met and a virtue at the Brooklyn Museum.
Rethinking American Art offers a long view of the field from the rare perspective of a scholar/curator/collector, because the author himself has amassed a significant collection (which he modestly does not mention). He has a special understanding of the range of enthusiasms that drove all these constituencies, and how they shaped the canon. Stebbins is a natural storyteller, and the book resonates with an easy and affable yet authoritative tone of reminiscence.
Given its combination of memoir and historical survey, it occasionally jumps from topic to topic, and its coverage of themes varies. It is not a comprehensive history, and it skims over ground that has already been well covered, while striving to fill gaps on less studied topics. The book is full of gems in the form of remarkable behind-the-scenes stories, vivid sketches of key people, and mini-reviews of exhibitions, books, and installations, all providing the sensation of unexpectedly falling down a rabbit hole—but a fascinating one.
This is not one but three rather different books under one overarching theme. Part 1 points out important foundational works in the field and key books and articles that underpin his survey. Part 2, “The Collectors,” forms the heart of the book and represents a unique contribution to scholarship, recounting the stories of key figures which are well-researched but also told with relish and appreciation. In a period when collectors are sometimes treated with suspicion and the worst motives are assumed, it is valuable to have accounts that highlight their commitment, passion, and sincerity.
An important distinction between the sections involves the passage of time. The book traces two very different kinds of canons—the one formed around the time that the works were made and those of later periods. While the canon of or near the period can shed great light on artworks, the canons of later periods say more about the era itself than the by-then historic works under discussion. As Stebbins conveys, the canon evolves into a tool for critics, dealers, and scholars of later periods to advance various agendas of their own.
As time passes the constituencies forming the canon evolve, and by the final section, the canon is no longer shaped by the parties that Stebbins described at the beginning of the book. The artists who created these works are long deceased; collectors are not a force, since the market for historic works is no longer very active; and critics rarely engage with historic art in any significant way. As a result, the development of the historic American art canon is left to scholars and curators, and it is interesting to see the path that they have taken as it is addressed in part 3.
As the book moves forward into the twenty-first century, Stebbins observes the shift from the criteria of quality for the “traditional” canon to the “moral imperatives” of the “anti-racist” canon (283)—that is, the artwork’s value in advancing efforts at diversity and political activism. He presents the dilemma between quality and political utility when he asks, “How far should the bar be lowered for worthy artists who lacked much talent? Every collector and every curator struggles to balance aesthetic quality with important political and cultural considerations” (362). He hints at the answer in an expanded canon based on quality when he quotes Paul Chaat Smith’s declaration that the final test of parity will be when we recognize that “most Indian art isn’t very good, just as most Black or Chinese or gay art, most art period, isn’t very good either” (357). Smith suggests that truly equal treatment can only be achieved with the return of quality as the primary criteria.
Rethinking American Art is refreshing and inspiring. The book is incredibly valuable for students of American art (or anyone in the field under the age of sixty), for young curators, and for aspiring collectors in any area of art. It should be the next book read immediately after an initial survey of American art because it shows how those surveys were created and alerts scholars to the important events, people, and foundational studies that underpin them.
Notes
[1] Stebbins mentions that Price is the husband of distinguished scholar Aimée Brown Price, who is a member of the Association of Historians of Nineteenth-Century Art.
[2] This is somewhat at odds with Crystal Bridges Curator Mindy Besaw’s declaration that “we needed to learn how to unlearn the canon,” which is quoted at the start of the chapter (275).