Annotating The New Union Club: Project Narrative
by Temi Odumosu and David SchwittekTemi Odumosu is an art historian and curator at the University of Washington Information School. Her scholarship involves Afro-diasporic memory work, interrogating the visual politics and legacies of colonialism, and paying particular attention to how collections steward historical artifacts, physically and virtually online. Her publications include “The Crying Child: On Colonial Archives, Digitisation, and Ethics of Care in the Cultural Commons” (2020) and “Approaching Colonial Photographs with Care” (2024) for the project Digital Benin. Through cultural practice, Odumosu develops collaborative interventions with contemporary artists, designers, and curators that are focused on repair. Examples of this work include the sound installation What Lies Unspoken: Sounding the Colonial Archive (2017) at the Royal Danish Library and Statens Museum for Kunst in Copenhagen, Denmark; and the exhibitions Threshold(s) (2019) at the Center for Art on Migration Politics in Copenhagen, and The Dream Keeper: Cecilia Germain (2021) at Botkyrka Konstall in Stockholm, Sweden.
Email the author: todumosu[at]uw.edu
David Schwittek is associate professor of graphic design and digital media at Lehman College, City University of New York (CUNY). His creative work spans documentary filmmaking, interactive media, and socially engaged design. He teaches courses in animation, motion graphics, and design theory, and is the founding organizer of the CUNY Animation Consortium, an initiative supporting animation programs across the CUNY system. His interdisciplinary work often explores issues of power, representation, and historical memory through visual and interactive forms.
Email the author: david.schwittek[at]lehman.cuny.edu
Citation: Temi Odumosu and David Schwittek, “Project Narrative,” in Temi Odumosu, “Annotating The New Union Club: A Case Study on Critical Praxis for Digital Art Histories,” Nineteenth-Century Art Worldwide 24, no. 2 (Summer 2025), https://doi.org/10.29411/ncaw.2025.24.2.2.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License
unless otherwise noted.
Your browser will either open the file, download it to a folder, or display a dialog with options.
Scholarly Article|Curator’s Welcome|Explore the Print |Project Narrative
Working with Difficult Artworks in the Time of AI
by Temi Odumosu
Art historians tend to follow artworks around as a necessary part of our analytical methods. But occasionally we stumble on images that haunt or follow us, with minimal effort on our part, because they insist on being noticed and seen. I feel that way about The New Union Club (1819) by George Cruikshank and Frederick Marryat—an audacious, complicated, horribly racist caricature of the antislavery movement in Britain that somehow manages to communicate more strongly in the present than its original makers may have intended. It is the kind of artwork that draws you close by necessity, in part because it is so detailed in its contempt and mockery but also because, as a viewer, you very quickly become aware of the immense labor required to make such an image. Nineteenth-century caricatures like this one were etched by hand, in reverse, on treated metal before being eaten away by acid, inked, pressed into paper, and then hand colored. The artwork measures 35 x 52 cm—at least a half meter wide and a third high. It was not an experiment or a mistake; the image was made with intention.
The New Union Club resurfaced for me, after a long hiatus, because of a podcast conversation I was invited to participate in by cultural historian and producer Michael Ohajuru. He was creating an episode for the BP2 Podcast on the Black Londoner and street entertainer William “Billy” Waters, who is represented in the print as well as in other illustrations and ephemera from the period.[1] When Michael asked me to join historians S. I. Martin and Gretchen Gerzina for a conversation about how Waters featured in these images, I looked again at the caricature in detail, to refresh my memory and consider what I might say. It was after we had completed recording the episode that a dialogue ensued about how to the make the print more accessible for online study, so that users could click on figures and find out more about who was represented, especially given that Waters was one of several recognizable Black people depicted in the print. We started by talking about ways to do this as a stand-alone web experience, which left me with a design challenge that I ruminated on for over a month. But, given my recent research on the ethics of digitizing colonial images, it soon became clear to me that making a virtual exhibition needed more than a technological approach.[2] For a new generation of viewers, such a presentation required critical contextualization—an opportunity to reflect on what it means to share such difficult imagery online in this current sociopolitical climate.
Digital Art History
Nineteenth-Century Art Worldwide (NCAW) offers a unique opportunity for art historians who are interested in developing a digital project that explores curatorial practices in a peer-reviewed publication. So, in the summer of 2023, I approached editor Carey Gibbons with the “elevator pitch” for this project, which I expressed as “a speculative object lesson on the possibilities for curating difficult colonial artworks online.” From there we entered into a lengthy conversation about the practicalities of digital-humanities work and the resources and team required to complete all the components of the project. Initially, there were many (too many) moving parts. In the early design phase, I had envisioned a virtual exhibition room where people could engage with the print alongside related artworks and through multimedia components that included sound, videos, and links to historical and contemporary documents associated with the print. Very quickly I realized that all this information would be too much for a viewing experience that we wanted to be thoughtful and intentional. I eventually settled on annotation as a curatorial methodology that offered precision for image interpretation and information networking but still made room for independent engagement with the artwork. After several conversations and proposal revisions for NCAW, we worked together on an application for a Digital Project Grant from the Paul Mellon Centre for Studies in British Art in London, which we were awarded. I owe a thousand thanks to its adjudication committee for supporting this work.
“Annotating The New Union Club” is really an attempt to think in a collaborative and multidisciplinary way about what it takes to make visual information—specifically, colonial information—available for research and public engagement online. On a conceptual level it grapples with the perceived neutrality of a cultural commons with open-access virtual collections, asserting that digital surrogates of real things are, like the things themselves, contested and affecting and have complicated cultural lives. Thus, the project is involved in an open debate about art history in the time of AI, the politics of visibility and representation, and the ethics of information sharing. That said, from a research perspective and despite its crude rendering, The New Union Club is also an information resource—a peculiarly detailed record of colonial relationships, citations, and activities that include African peoples in the fight for emancipation from slavery. In this sense, our project conversely asks whether (and if) this artwork can be approached differently—as a Black Atlantic record used to redress narrative imbalances in the production of history.
Collaborative Ethics
There are several dimensions to this project, which is made possible through collaboration. All have at their core a critical standpoint of ethical reflexivity, meaning an approach to design, research, and writing that is attentive to the various possibilities for causing distress and which proactively reimagines praxis. In the scholarly article, this standpoint has informed my approach, which includes writing in several tones of voice; making careful decisions about what images should (and should not be) shared and discussed; and utilizing small annotative choices in the use of language, such as strikethroughs and/or redactions. In the spirit of “viral justice”—a microtheory proposed by sociologist Ruha Benjamin suggesting that small things can lead to exponentially larger change—all of these actions indicate what we have chosen to tolerate and accept here, within the editorial and curatorial space of this work.[3] “No, not anymore,” or “No, not here,” are the kinds of curatorial assertions and refusals that we embedded in decision making, from text to code.[4]
Similarly, we created the technical dimensions of this project with a healthy amount of questioning and moments for pause. Designer Dave Schwittek has been instrumental in realizing the interactive feature. Dave and I discussed at length how to build an accessible space for showcasing scholarly commentary and interpretation of an artwork while including features that guide the user experience (UX), making people aware of the tensions involved in looking at this challenging print. So many moments along this design journey proved that without ethical attentiveness, technology quite easily extends dehumanizing or oppressive logics. This means we debated everything, from the use of “pointers” to the color and exact positioning of highlighted areas. We asked: If we use a pop-up window, where will it come from, and how will it support or hinder the viewing experience? Is it possible to block the downloading of an image? What filtering choices should we offer users as they engage with this charged, visually arresting artwork? When do content advisories work, and where do they fail? And, how much additional information is enough, or too much, given the nature of caricature as its own form of politicized newscasting? We attempted to answer these questions through design decisions, such as offering different viewing filters that allow users to see the print in either black and white or in color and to view annotations by category, enabling users to independently select how they engage with the artwork. These decisions should not be considered final directives but rather corrective gestures.
One further dimension of this project has been the development of experimental visual-dialogue workshops aimed at facilitating live conversation about The New Union Club, including its impact and relevance in the current moment. The workshops were codesigned at the University of Washington (UW) with human-centered design and engineering graduate student Xiaoyi Xue. We invited graduate students in museology and library and information science at the Information School (iSchool) to ideate and think out loud about critical curation and the challenges of sensitive content sharing online and in exhibition spaces. Those wonderful conversations helped us to more concretely see how the artwork communicates to people who are invested in curation and memory work but had never seen the print. You can hear moments from the discussions in the Welcome Video that accompanies the interactive feature. Through those conversations—indeed, throughout the whole project experience—we learned that choosing to live with oppressive imagery without some kind of intervention has real consequences and that historical documents and artworks still have relevance for us in the present but need to be handled with care. What form that care takes, and how it is practiced, ultimately involve the kind of critical questioning we are advocating for in this project and, more broadly, for digital art history.
Acknowledgments
It really does take a village to make a digital art history project. First, I want to thank NCAW digital art history editor Carey Gibbons, co-managing editor Isabel Taube, and executive editor Kim Orcutt for their indominable commitment to this project and for receiving, with much grace and good humor, my provocations to art history and to the rules of scholarly-article production. I know we have challenged each other with rigor and integrity in ways that have transformed the outcome for the better. I also want to thank designer Dave Schwittek for his openness and critical insights throughout this project, and for making its technical aspects a creative process for all of us. The interactive feature, which reflects our debates and conversations, simply would not be possible without the careful attention he has given it. I also want to thank NCAW copyeditor Robyn Roslak and web developer Allan McLeod for shepherding the various parts of this project with equal care, ensuring they are in publishable format.
Much gratitude goes to our student research assistants from the UW, who have been some of my most important teachers during this project. Thank you to informatics undergraduate Amy Shanna Sun, whose research on sensitive-content filters was invaluable to the process of developing UX strategies for print engagement. Our conversations at the Frye Art Museum and the Henry Art Gallery in Seattle—in front of artworks by Hank Willis Thomas, Stephanie Syjuco, and Martin Wong—were truly memorable and important experiences that inspired several of the design elements in our interactive feature. And huge thanks to Xiaoyi Xue, who as mentioned, codesigned this project’s visual dialogue workshops with me and was a thoughtful steward and witness to the whole process. I am so grateful for your critical insights and enthusiasm, the care with which you approached this work intellectually, and the practical tasks you undertook hosting and supporting workshop participants.
For their role in creating a compelling and welcoming audio environment to support our experimental workshop conversations, I also want to extend huge thanks to sound engineer Ayesha Ubayatilaka and administrative coordinator Levi Fuller at the Jack Straw Cultural Center in Seattle. Finally, I want to recognize those brave students in the UW iSchool who joined the conversation space and shared their thoughts with honesty, openness, and vulnerability. I so appreciate your trust in us as a team and in the entire workshop process.
For time spent in collections, I want to thank Cynthia Roman and Susan Walker at the Lewis Walpole Library at Yale University, who welcomed me back to the collection, after years away from studying caricatures, with such warmth and kindness. It was a delight to spend time talking about, and interacting with, The New Union Club in more creative ways. Thank you both for reminding me that I am still part of a community of art historical practice, even if I currently wear different disciplinary shoes!
Last, I want to thank Ricardo H. Wijndal for supporting and championing me throughout this experience of returning again (somewhat ambivalently) to the archive and for being a diligent witness, producing new documents through videos and photographs. As always, you helped bring my creative visions to life.
Notes
[1] Gretchen Gerzina, Temi Odumosu, and S. I. Martin, “Billy Waters in The New Union Club (1819),” April 20, 2023, in BP2 Podcast, produced by Michael Ohajuru and The Black Presence in British Portraiture Network, 35:37, The BP2 Podcast Episode 6: Billy Waters in The New Union Club.
[2] Temi Odumosu, “The Crying Child: On Colonial Archives, Digitization, and Ethics of Care in the Cultural Commons.” Current Anthropology 61, no. S22 (2020): S289–302, doi:10.1086/710062.
[3] Benjamin writes about this microtheory of change: “If the COVID-19 pandemic has taught us anything, it’s that something almost undetectable can be deadly, and that we can transmit it without even knowing. Doesn’t this imply that small things, seemingly minor actions, decisions, and habits could have exponential effects in the other direction, tipping the scales toward justice: affirming life, fostering well-being, and invigorating society?” Ruha Benjamin, Viral Justice: How We Grow the World We Want (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2022), 21.
[4] On the politics of refusal, see Eve Tuck and K. Wayne Yang, “R-words: Refusing Research,” in Humanizing Research: Decolonizing Qualitative Inquiry with Youth and Communities, ed. Django Paris and Maisha T. Winn (Los Angeles: Sage, 2014), 223–48; and Tina Campt, “Black Visuality and the Practice of Refusal,” Women & Performance: A Journal of Feminist Theory 29, no. 1 (2019): 79–87.
Ethical and Theoretical Foundations of the UI/UX Design
by David Schwittek
Navigating the Tension between User-Centered Design and Historical Reverence
The design of “Annotating The New Union Club” confronts a central tension in user interface/user experience (UI/UX) practice: balancing conventional, user-centered design—which prioritizes ease of access, clarity, and engagement—with the ethical responsibility to represent historical subjects with dignity and sensitivity. This tension becomes particularly acute when the subject matter involves the transatlantic slave trade and its enduring impact on Black communities.
Traditional design methodologies often aim for intuitive navigation, frictionless interaction, and visual immediacy. Yet in the context of this project, such priorities risk commodifying trauma and reducing subjects to objects of analytical scrutiny. My approach, therefore, was to resist design instincts that emphasize polish and efficiency in favor of strategies that make space for ethical hesitation, reflection, and opacity.
I was solely responsible for the design and development of the interactive feature, working closely with Temi Odumosu—the project’s author—and the editorial team at Nineteenth-Century Art Worldwide. In addition to responding to their conceptual and curatorial feedback, I researched ways to create a durable, interactive experience, prioritizing long-term accessibility and archival stability. This required identifying open-source codebases and plug-ins built with web standards in mind while also ensuring that the feature enabled deep, close-looking functionality—akin to the experience of encountering the print in a physical archive.
As a designer whose practice spans graphic design, motion media, and interactive systems, I approach UI/UX as a field involving narrative and ethical negotiation—especially when dealing with visual archives of oppression and resistance. I am also an activist with a deep commitment to social justice, and I work to infuse my design practice with this philosophy. For me, design is not merely a technical exercise or aesthetic endeavor but a platform for critical engagement with systems of power, historical memory, and cultural representation. In the case of this project, the interactive feature serves as a platform for critical engagement by framing content in a way that destabilizes passive consumption—prompting users to reflect on how they encounter and interpret historical imagery rather than absorbing it uncritically.
This project pushed me to interrogate some of the defaults in my own design habits, particularly the drive toward seamless interaction and visual fluency. In commercial contexts, designers are often encouraged to remove friction, streamline access, and deliver content quickly. But the nature of this project required a slower, more deliberate methodology—one that foregrounds dignity and context over convenience.
Instead of guiding users smoothly from one point to another, I tried to build an interface that allowed for pause, contemplation, and responsible engagement. Features like content warnings, layered annotations, and subdued interactivity were introduced not as obstacles but as ethical design choices. After consulting with Odumosu, one example of how I designed for ethical hesitation was the implementation of an entry disclaimer that appears as soon as the user launches the feature—a convention generally discouraged in standard UI/UX practice for interrupting user flow. This pop-up requires acknowledgment before continuing and is paired with a grayscale filter applied to the entire image until the user engages with the print and has the option to remove the filter. This visual restraint discourages passive browsing and signals that the material demands careful, intentional engagement. This approach challenged me to work against optimization in order to allow for a different kind of experience—one grounded in care rather than control.
Reconciling Technological Constraints and Ethical Aims
Several unexpected moments emerged where the possibilities and limits of the technology became sites for creative and ethical negotiation. OpenSeadragon, chosen for its deep-zoom functionality, enabled an almost microscopic level of engagement with the print. This was technically useful but also raised critical concerns. Such intense visual scrutiny can echo the historical gaze that objectified and dehumanized Black subjects—replicating, in digital form, the invasive logics of surveillance and clinical observation.
This recognition led me to question not only what the interface revealed, but how it revealed it. The interaction patterns of contemporary web design—clicking, zooming, hovering—are often framed as neutral, default behaviors. But these seemingly innocuous actions carry histories of power and control. I’m reminded of Keith Obadike’s early net art, which was an attempt—in the artist’s own words—“to comment on this odd Euro colonialist narrative that exists on the web and Black peoples’ position within that narrative.” He points out the irony that “there are browsers called Explorer and Navigator that take you to explore the Amazon or trade in the eBay. It’s all just too blatant to ignore.”[1] His sharp critique underscores how even the basic metaphors and behaviors built into web interfaces can reproduce colonial logics, casting users as discoverers and data as territory.
Furthermore, Simone Browne reminds us that “Blackness [is] a key site through which surveillance is practiced, narrated, and enacted.”[2] The interface’s capacity to magnify, isolate, and frame carries with it the risk of reinscribing historical techniques of racialized control, even when deployed with educational or curatorial intent. Browne’s framing reinforces the idea that technologies of observation—from slave ships to digital tools—have long functioned as mechanisms for racialized control and classification. In this light, zooming, annotating, and—crucially—spotlighting, are not ideologically neutral actions but practices that must be carefully interrogated and reframed when applied to histories of racial violence.
To address this, I implemented an interface that mediates the zooming experience through color-coded overlays, subtle hover states, and informational sidebars—drawing directly on Odumosu’s vision for a more thoughtful and caring mode of interaction. Her color-coded strategy shaped the interface’s narrative logic, encouraging users to engage with the annotations through thematic layers—exploring individuals such as abolitionist figures, references such as popular songs, and symbolic devices like metaphors conveying perspectives on antislavery. The content within these annotations would have been legible to many nineteenth-century viewers but is likely opaque to a twenty-first-century audience.
From a technical standpoint, the decision to forgo a traditional database in favor of a flat, standards-based data structure keeps the project lightweight, transparent, and free of external dependencies. This means the content is stored in basic table-format files (CSV), not in a database or proprietary platform. This eliminates the need for third-party systems or software that may become obsolete.
These discussions—between myself, Odumosu, and the editorial team at Nineteenth-Century Art Worldwide—regularly pushed the project away from technical expediency and toward greater ethical accountability.
Technical Summary and the Importance of Standards-Based Development
“Annotating The New Union Club” is built entirely with open, standards-based web technologies—HTML, CSS, JavaScript, and CSV—chosen for their accessibility, stability, and archival longevity. The project avoids proprietary systems, ensuring it remains browser-native and free of dependencies that could limit its future usability. OpenSeadragon was selected specifically because of its widespread use in the digital humanities and archival imaging, allowing for high-resolution engagement without requiring users to install plug-ins or external frameworks.
Overlays on the image of The New Union Club are color-coded into three thematic categories that shape how the print can be explored and read: blue indicates individual portraits, yellow marks cultural references, and pink highlights symbolism. On hovering over a specific individual, reference, or symbol, the rest of the image is subtly darkened, bringing the hovered area into sharper relief to encourage focused viewing. When clicked, the full image is filtered in the overlay’s category color, and a sidebar modal appears with contextual information and supplementary image content, transforming the interface into a layered narrative experience.
This technological foundation supports not only preservation and access but also aligns with the values of transparency and openness. The code structure enables others to adapt or build upon the project, while the lightweight footprint ensures it remains accessible across devices and browsers. Ultimately, the use of standards-based development reinforces the project’s dual goals: to ethically engage with a complex visual artifact, and to do so in a way that can be sustained, extended, and shared.
Rethinking the Foundations of Interaction
If I were to begin the project again, I would be interested in reimagining the interface from the ground up—not just in terms of structure or layout, but in terms of how interaction itself is understood. Clicking, hovering, zooming: these actions are often treated as neutral within UI/UX design, but in the context of visual material tied to racial violence and colonialism they carry weight. In short, they become acts of scrutiny, tools of exposure.
It would have been fascinating to develop an interface that interrupts these mechanics—one that resists the gaze, that conceals rather than reveals, or that introduces ambiguity as a form of ethical resistance. While this interactive feature begins to gesture toward that possibility, starting from this philosophical standpoint might yield an even more radical design outcome. My hope is that this project can offer a model for how digital tools might embrace ambiguity and ethical uncertainty as design strategies, especially when dealing with traumatic or politically charged imagery and historical material. To support this, I’ve made the codebase client-side accessible (meaning it is stored locally in a user’s browser, uncompressed and easily readable) and thoroughly commented so that others can adapt the feature’s tool to their own imagery and data with minimal modification. This project is not a fixed solution but instead an invitation to collaborate and design with care.
Notes
[1] K. T. Obadike, “All Too Real: The Tale of an On-Line Black Sale,” interview by Coco Fusco, Mendi + Keith Obadike (Blacknetart.com), September 24, 2001, https://blacknetart.com/.
[2] Simone Browne, Dark Matters: On the Surveillance of Blackness (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2015), 9.