Volume 24, Issue 2 | Summer 2025

Annotating The New Union Club: Interactive Feature

by Temi Odumosu and David Schwittek

Scholarly Article|Curator’s Welcome|Explore the Print |Project Narrative

Overview

by Temi Odumosu

“Annotating The New Union Club” is an interactive digital experience that supports engagement with a nineteenth-century political caricature about antislavery. This complex and overtly racist artwork is available to consult in at least eight museum and library collections, but with limited, outdated, or general descriptions that do not provide the kind of context required to articulate the print’s challenges, educational value, and meaning as a historical document. This project uses digital annotation, in combination with user experience (UX) design strategies for engaging sensitive content, as an alternative approach to artwork curation and interpretation, allowing users to consider their own role as witnessing subjects and to explore the print’s provocative themes and hidden messages through an introductory but contemporary critical lens.

Created by George Cruikshank (1792–1878) and Frederick Marryat (1792–1848) and published in London during the years between the abolition of slavery and full emancipation, The New Union Club (1819) is a highly charged but compelling piece of British colonial art that examines antislavery politics between England, the United States, and the Caribbean through the medium of graphic caricature. The print employs grotesque humor to diminish antislavery campaigners by reframing their efforts as misguided and self-interested philanthropy. It generally mocks their investments in London’s African and Asian populations and, more specifically, their emerging international relationship with Haiti’s first Black monarch, King Henri Christophe (1767–1820). Throughout this visual critique, comic devices such as puns, metaphors, and wordplay encode Blackness with a troubling array of negative stereotypes that all combine in fervent opposition to the idea of racial mixing. However, within this biased information space we also find necessary points of connection to African-diasporic narratives and life stories that need to be taken seriously. In this sense the print also functions as cultural portraiture.

From a scholarly perspective, the print’s detailed and multilayered references make it an informative document for postcolonial study. In the early part of the twentieth century, art historians and cataloguers described The New Union Club as “important,” “valuable,” and a “high point” in Cruikshank’s oeuvre, given its skilled rendering as a work of illustration. There is contemporary awareness that the print would be more prominently curated in the genre of caricature and in discussions about British antislavery were it not for its outrageous racism. Within this project’s viewing experience, we introduce users to different ways of reading this print and, furthermore, actively focus attention on the portrayal of African-diasporic narratives by incorporating alternative archival and artwork references, along with lesser-known historical information. Using digital annotation in this way as a form of extended cultural commentary and document networking, we aim to create a critical space for reflection on what can be obscured through traditional record keeping.

With the artwork readily accessible in several collections online, our project has asked serious questions about access, and debated the range of sensitivities involved in restaging or reproducing overtly racist content. Throughout the interactive feature, we have prototyped design ideas that aim to cultivate awareness about the implications of digital visibility in an image culture characterized by misrepresentation and distortion across various platforms. Specifically, we draw inspiration from critical cataloguing work in archival and library sciences, and value sensitive design for UX, which asserts the need for ethical guardrails in the sharing and description of biased and oppressive information. Protection, filtering, and redaction are refusal strategies we have also identified in work by contemporary artists who use colonial imagery for the purpose of resignification. Together, these inspirations have helped us to curate interactive moments, including the welcome video above, which are sensitized to the effects of looking at distressing visual content online.

Overview|Explore the Print

Explore the print in a new window